By Mark R. Wicclair

Traditionally linked to army carrier, conscientious objection has turn into an important phenomenon in wellbeing and fitness care. Mark Wicclair bargains a finished moral research of conscientious objection in 3 consultant well-being care professions: medication, nursing and pharmacy. He significantly examines severe positions: the 'incompatibility thesis', that it truly is opposite to the pro duties of practitioners to refuse provision of any carrier in the scope in their specialist competence; and 'conscience absolutism', that they need to be exempted from appearing any motion opposite to their sense of right and wrong. He argues for a compromise strategy that contains conscience-based refusals in the limits of distinctive moral constraints. He additionally explores conscientious objection by way of scholars in all the 3 professions, discusses judgment of right and wrong safeguard laws and conscience-based refusals by means of pharmacies and hospitals, and analyzes numerous situations. His publication is a priceless source for students, execs, trainees, scholars, and somebody drawn to this more and more vital point of future health care

Show description

Read or Download Conscientious Objection in Health Care: An Ethical Analysis PDF

Best medical ethics books

Quality of Life and Human Difference: Genetic Testing, Health Care, and Disability

The position of caliber checks in social coverage, particularly wellbeing and fitness coverage, and moral and social matters raised by means of prenatal checking out for incapacity are mentioned during this research. A subject of the literature has been the function performed by way of debatable assumptions in regards to the caliber of lifetime of individuals with disabilities.

Transhumanism and Transcendence: Christian Hope in an Age of Technological Enhancement

The undying human wish to be extra attractive, clever, fit, athletic, or younger has given upward push in our time to applied sciences of human enhancement. Athletes use medicines to extend their power or stamina; plastic surgery is time-honored to enhance actual visual appeal; thousands of guys take medications like Viagra to reinforce sexual functionality.

Religious Perspectives on Human Vulnerability in Bioethics

With the development of biomedicine, sure contributors and teams are susceptible as a result of their incapacities to protect themselves. The foreign Bioethics Committee as a UNESCO operating crew has for the final numerous years devoted to deepen this precept of human vulnerability and private integrity.

Additional info for Conscientious Objection in Health Care: An Ethical Analysis

Example text

To respect another as a person is, insofar as possible, to respect the expression and exercise, if not the content, of a person’s most fundamental convictions” (Benjamin vol. I 2004: 513–17). Judith Daar presents an autonomy-based defense of conscientious objection by physicians (Daar 1993: 1241–89). However, her focus is on cases in which physicians believe that continued life-extending treatments are “futile,” and their refusals are based primarily on considerations of professional integrity.

However, the references to “a professional brother” and “future usefulness” (presumably as a physician) seem to suggest that Bell’s exception to a duty not to withhold services has more to do with maintaining a physician’s standing as a member of the medical profession (or maintaining the status of the medical profession generally) than with enabling physicians to follow the dictates of their conscience and protect their personal moral integrity. That is, Bell’s statement addresses refusals based on professional integrity rather than conscience-based refusals.

Chervenak and McCullough offer the following illustration of direct referral: For example, an obstetrician suspects appendicitis in a pregnant patient. As the patient’s fiduciary, the obstetrician has a beneficence-based obligation to see to it that this patient receives prompt surgical attention, which obligation is fulfilled by assuring that a surgeon does indeed see the patient promptly. g. the names and contact information of providers from whom they can receive the service at issue). 11 Whereas it might be plausible to ascribe moral complicity in relation to direct referrals, Chervenak and McCullough maintain that a physician who provides an indirect referral “cannot reasonably be understood to be a party to, or complicit in, a subsequent decision that is the sole province of the patient’s subsequent exercise of autonomy in consultation with a referral 11 In cases of elective abortion, Chervenak and McCullough claim that obstetrician-gynecologists with conscience-based objections are at least obligated to provide indirect referral to an organization such as Planned Parenthood to protect patients from harm.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.60 of 5 – based on 46 votes