By Ronald P. Hamel, James J. Walter

Prior to now few many years, high-profile situations like that of Terry Schiavo have fueled the general public debate over forgoing or chickening out synthetic foodstuff and hydration from sufferers in a continual vegetative nation (PVS). those situations, no matter if related to adults or youngsters, have pressured many to start considering in a measured and cautious manner concerning the ethical legitimacy of permitting sufferers to die. Can households forgo or withdraw man made hydration and meals from their family while no desire of restoration turns out attainable? Many Catholics comprehend that Catholic ethical theology has formulated a well-developed and well-reasoned place in this and different end-of-life concerns, one who distinguishes among ''ordinary'' and ''extraordinary'' remedy. yet fresh occasions have prompted uncertainty and confusion or even acrimony one of the devoted. In his 2004 allocution, Pope John Paul II proposed that man made nutrients and hydration is a sort of simple care, therefore suggesting that the availability of such care to sufferers neurologically incapable of feeding themselves may be thought of an ethical legal responsibility. The pope's tackle, which looked as if it would have provided a brand new improvement to a long time of Catholic future health care ethics, sparked a contentious debate one of the trustworthy over how top to regard completely subconscious sufferers in the tenets of Catholic morality. during this entire and balanced quantity, Ronald Hamel and James Walter current twenty-one essays and articles, contributed by way of physicians, clergy, theologians, and ethicists, to mirror the spectrum of views at the matters that outline the Catholic debate. equipped into six elements, each one with its personal advent, the essays provide medical details on PVS and feeding tubes; discussions at the Catholic ethical culture and the way it'd be altering; ecclesiastical and pastoral statements on forgoing or retreating foodstuff and hydration; theological and moral analyses at the factor; observation on Pope John Paul II's 2004 allocution; and the theological remark, court docket judgements, and public coverage because of the Clarence Herbert and Claire Conroy felony situations. A helpful source for college kids and students, this teachable quantity invitations theological discussion and moral dialogue on probably the most contested matters within the church this day.

Show description

Read Online or Download Artificial Nutrition and Hydration and the Permanently Unconscious Patient: The Catholic Debate PDF

Best medical ethics books

Quality of Life and Human Difference: Genetic Testing, Health Care, and Disability

The function of caliber checks in social coverage, specially health and wellbeing coverage, and moral and social matters raised through prenatal trying out for incapacity are mentioned during this research. A subject matter of the literature has been the function performed through arguable assumptions concerning the caliber of lifetime of individuals with disabilities.

Transhumanism and Transcendence: Christian Hope in an Age of Technological Enhancement

The undying human wish to be extra appealing, clever, fit, athletic, or younger has given upward push in our time to applied sciences of human enhancement. Athletes use medicinal drugs to extend their energy or stamina; plastic surgery is widespread to enhance actual visual appeal; thousands of guys take medicinal drugs like Viagra to augment sexual functionality.

Religious Perspectives on Human Vulnerability in Bioethics

With the development of biomedicine, yes contributors and teams are susceptible due to their incapacities to safeguard themselves. The foreign Bioethics Committee as a UNESCO operating workforce has for the final a number of years devoted to deepen this precept of human vulnerability and private integrity.

Additional info for Artificial Nutrition and Hydration and the Permanently Unconscious Patient: The Catholic Debate

Sample text

Bioethics and the Handicapped Newborn (New York: Paulist Press, 1988), 85–100. 9. F. De Vitoria, Relectiones Theologiae (Lugdini, 1587), Relectio IX, de Temperentia, n. 1 (translated as in Cronin, Conserving Human Life, p. 35). 10. F. De Vitoria, Relectiones Theologiae, Relectio IX, de Temperentia, n. 12 (translated as in Cronin, Conserving Human Life, p. 36); and F. De Vitoria, Comentarios a la Secunda Secundae de Santo Tomas 48       (Salamanca, ed.

If because of some current pathology, the person requires that these be supplied by technological means, then it would seem that the same moral principles can be applied to determine the respective moral obligations to initiate or continue life conserving procedures. By technological means we are circumventing an obstacle that prevents food and water (or oxygen) from entering the body in the normal manner. 53 And these theologians were talking about ordinary “food,” taken in everyday ways. To be sure, decisions to withdraw medically assisted nutrition and hydration from PVS patients will be emotionally difficult for family members and medical professionals.

232). But this misrepresents the nature of the therapy. No significant moral difference exists between medically assisted nutrition and hydration and, say, mechanical ventilation, which most everyone agrees is a medical treatment. Both are administered and supervised by medical professionals, and both are geared toward restoring a vital physiological function. As Albert Moraczewski remarks: Oxygen, water, and food are all necessary elements for maintaining life. If because of some current pathology, the person requires that these be supplied by technological means, then it would seem that the same moral principles can be applied to determine the respective moral obligations to initiate or continue life conserving procedures.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.90 of 5 – based on 49 votes